top of page
Search

Measurement & Maintenance: How Do We Maintain Our Automated Test Suite?

  • Writer: QTECH
    QTECH
  • Dec 2, 2025
  • 3 min read

Automated testing saves time and improves software quality, but only if the test suite stays reliable and relevant. When the application changes, test scripts can break or become outdated, leading to false failures or missed bugs. Maintaining an automated test suite is a continuous effort that requires clear strategies to keep tests useful and reduce brittleness. This post explores practical ways to measure and maintain your automated tests so they remain a strong asset throughout your software lifecycle.


Eye-level view of a computer screen showing automated test results with graphs and logs
Automated test results dashboard showing pass/fail rates and logs

Understanding Why Test Suites Become Brittle


Test scripts become brittle when small changes in the application cause tests to fail even though the core functionality works fine. Common causes include:


  • UI changes: Moving buttons, renaming fields, or redesigning pages can break tests that rely on specific element locators.

  • Timing issues: Tests that do not wait properly for elements to load can fail intermittently.

  • Hardcoded data: Using fixed values in tests makes them fragile when data changes.

  • Lack of modularity: Tests that duplicate code or mix concerns are harder to update.


Recognizing these causes helps teams design tests that adapt better to change.


Measuring Test Suite Health


Before fixing problems, you need to measure your test suite’s current state. Key metrics include:


  • Test pass rate: Percentage of tests passing in each run. A sudden drop signals issues.

  • Flaky test rate: Tests that pass sometimes and fail other times. High flakiness reduces trust.

  • Test coverage: How much of the application code or features are exercised by tests.

  • Execution time: Long-running suites slow feedback and reduce productivity.

  • Maintenance effort: Time spent fixing broken tests or updating scripts.


Tracking these metrics over time reveals trends and helps prioritize maintenance work.


Strategies to Prevent Test Scripts from Becoming Outdated


Use Robust Element Locators


Avoid brittle selectors like absolute XPaths or IDs that change frequently. Instead:


  • Use stable attributes such as data-test IDs designed for testing.

  • Prefer CSS selectors or relative XPaths that rely on consistent structure.

  • Avoid relying on text labels that may change.


Implement Waits and Timeouts Properly


Tests should wait for elements to be ready before interacting. Use explicit waits rather than fixed delays. This reduces flaky failures caused by timing issues.


Modularize Test Code


Break tests into reusable functions or page objects. This makes updates easier because changes to UI locators or flows happen in one place, not across many scripts.


Parameterize Test Data


Use variables or external data sources instead of hardcoding values. This allows tests to run with different inputs and adapt to data changes.


Review and Refactor Regularly


Schedule periodic reviews of the test suite to remove obsolete tests, update scripts for new features, and refactor code for clarity.


Handling Application Changes Effectively


When the application changes, follow these steps to keep tests aligned:


  • Communicate early: Developers should inform testers about upcoming changes.

  • Analyze impact: Identify which tests cover affected areas.

  • Update tests promptly: Fix broken locators, adjust flows, or add new tests.

  • Run regression tests: Verify that fixes work and no new issues appear.

  • Automate notifications: Use CI tools to alert the team about test failures quickly.


Tools and Practices That Support Maintenance


  • Version control for tests: Store test scripts in repositories to track changes and roll back if needed.

  • Continuous integration (CI): Run tests automatically on code changes to catch issues early.

  • Test management tools: Organize tests, track results, and manage test data efficiently.

  • Flaky test detection: Use tools or scripts to identify and quarantine unstable tests.

  • Code reviews for tests: Apply the same review standards to test code as to application code.


Summary


Maintaining an automated test suite requires ongoing measurement and proactive care. By tracking key metrics, designing resilient tests, and responding quickly to application changes, teams can keep their test suites reliable and valuable. The goal is to reduce brittle failures and outdated scripts so automated testing continues to support fast, confident software delivery.


 
 
bottom of page